|Posted on February 22, 2015 at 1:20 PM|
Downs Sydrome, heart disease and Martial Training
Jeffrey A Hein, MS - Research Consultant: Jiu Jitsu Global Federation
To begin this article, I wish to be very clear on certain subjects that pertain to both instructors, parents, caregivers and practitioners of martial arts. The first area of concern is that all students who have disabilities should first have a thorough medical examination by their primary care physician to assess any medical conditions that need to be addressed when beginning a program of study in martial arts. An examination is not to preclude the disabled from being involved in martial arts, but to help instructors to design a program of study that meets the needs of the disabled student and will help the instructor to address the needs of the student. It is my opinion that all disabled students can participate in martial arts, but each student will bring certain limitations that need to be addressed and having a medical examination will help the instructor to design a program of study that is safe and will meet the needs and goals of the disabled practitioner.
Second, the disabled student should be under the supervision of their primary physician to assess their progress as well as to evaluate their progress in the practitioner’s physical condition. I suggest regular meetings with their primary physician in order evaluate any problems that may arise from training in martial arts. With proper medical supervision and having an instructor that is trained and understands the needs of the adaptive needs of their students will make for a safe environment that is a positive experience for both the instructor and practitioner alike. There are no two adaptive martial arts students that are exactly alike; thus it is the encumbrance of the instructor to become familiar with each disabled student and to work as a team with the disabled practitioner, primary physician, family members and care givers. This team approach will not only increase the safety of the practitioner and make for a positive experience for all involved.
Working with students who have downs syndrome present will several unique issues that need to be addressed. The first and foremost issue I will deal with in this article is congenital heart disease. Current medical research estimates that approximately 60% of all downs syndrome individuals have a congenital heart defect of some category. Abnormalities of the cardiovascular system are common in Down syndrome. Approximately half of all infants born with Down syndrome have a heart defect. Many of these defects have serious implications and it is important to understand them and how they may affect the child so that appropriate medical treatment may be provided. This presents certain risks with any kind of physical fitness program including martial arts. I will briefly exam the two most common heart disease issues, but first, I will give a complete overview of the congenital heart problems that a martial arts instructor may encounter when training an individual with Downs Syndrome
Congenital Heart Disease in Children with Down Syndrome
Children with Down syndrome are at a much higher risk for congenital heart disease. As a comparison: the incidence of congenital heart disease in the general population is 0.8 percent. The incidence of congenital heart disease in children with Down syndrome is between 40-60 percent. Some heart defects can be left alone with careful monitoring while others require surgery to correct the problem. The following types of heart defects in children with Down syndrome are discussed below.
Atrioventricular Septal Defects (AVSDs) – These are the most common in children with Down syndrome.
Ventricular Septal Defects (VSDs)
Atrial Septal Defects
Patent Ductus Arteriosus
Tetralogy of Fallot
Atrioventricular Septal Defects (AVSDs)
These heart defects are defined by a hole in the wall between the top chambers (atria) and bottom chambers (ventricles) and one common valve between the two areas. In some cases, there might not be a hole between the bottom chambers. Or the valves may not be joined together, but either or both might leak. This is known as valve incompetence.
Because of the high pressure in the left ventricle which is needed to pump the blood around the body, blood is forced through the holes in the central heart wall (septum) when the ventricle contracts. This increases the pressure in the right ventricle. This increased pressure (pulmonary hypertension) results in excess blood flow to the lungs. Some of the early symptoms seen are difficulty in eating, weight gain, fast irregular breathing and a degree of cyanosis (blueness) particularly noticeable around the mouth, fingers and toes. Clinical examination may show an enlarged heart and liver, and a diagnosis of ‘heart failure' may be given. This term is used because of the flow of blood from one side to the other; the heart has to work harder than normal causing the heart to fail to work normally. Not all children will exhibit symptoms early in life, and those that do will not always show all of these.Treatment
Early treatment may involve the use of diuretics to control the fluid retention around the body and to reduce the volume of blood in the circulation, thus making the heart's workload easier. These may be used in conjunction with other drugs that increase the contraction of the heart muscle.
Slow weight gain may indicate the need to use high-calorie formula increase calorie intake. Severe eating problems may warrant using a naso-gastric tube (through the nose and directly into the stomach) to help with proper nutrition.
The majority of cases of AVSD usually require surgical intervention; this generally takes place within the first six months of life.
Ventricular Septal Defects (VSDs)
In this defect there is a hole between the bottom chambers (pumping chambers or ventricles). Because of the higher pressure in the left side of the heart, this allows oxygenated blood to flow through the hole from the left to the right side of the heart, and back to the lungs, in addition to the normal flow.
The amount of blood flow from the left to right ventricle depends on the size of the hole and on the pressure between the ventricles. In other words, the higher the rate of flow means more strain on the heart. The abnormal blood flow is responsible for the murmur that may be heard. Generally patients with a small VSD will not exhibit symptoms (they are asymptomatic) and the problem may only be found when a murmur is detected upon routine examination. Patients with a moderate VSD may breathe quickly, exhibit poor weight gain, and be slower at eating. These children are also much more prone to chest infections. This tends to be more pronounced when the hole is large. As with ASVDs, patients with moderate or large holes usually require treatment with diuretics to control fluid retention and to reduce the volume of blood in the circulation may be used. Also, high-calorie formula or tube feedings might be necessary. Many VSDs will close spontaneously or get much smaller, so it is normal practice to leave a child with a small or moderate VSD and monitor their progress before deciding to operate. Surgery may be needed if there is failure to thrive despite medication, or concern about pulmonary hypertension. If a large VSD is present, surgery is almost always recommended. Atrial Septal Defects (ASDs). In this defect there is a hole between the top chambers (receiving chambers or atria). Because of the higher pressure in the left side of the heart, oxygenated blood flows through the hole from the left to the right side of the heart, and back to the lungs, in addition to the normal flow. There are three types of Atrial Septal Defect; the most common is when there is a hole in the middle of the central heart wall. Holes in the lower part of the septum, called the primum defect (partial atrioventricular septal defect), are often associated with a problem of the mitral valve that often results in a leak. Less common are sinus venosus defects or holes in the top of the septum. These are associated with an abnormality of the right upper lung vein. Generally patients with an ASD defect will exhibit no symptoms and the problem is only found when a routine clinical examination detects a heart murmur. Occasionally children with this problem will exhibit poor weight gain and a failure to thrive, and if there is mitral valve leakage there may be early symptoms of breathlessness. Small holes which allow little blood flow from left to right generally cause no problems. If they are located in the middle portion of the central heart wall, they may even close on their own. However, moderate and large holes do not close, and the extra work over the years places a strain on the right side of the heart causing an enlargement of both pumping chambers. Therefore, treatment (surgery) is usually recommended in the first few years of life for larger holes, before excessive strain has been placed on the heart. Patent Ductus Arteriosus (PDA). This defect is the continuance of a direct connection between the aorta and the lung (pulmonary) artery, which normally closes shortly after birth. A baby in the womb is supplied oxygen by the placenta via the umbilical cord. The baby's lungs are not expanded and require only a small amount of blood for them to grow. The ductus is a blood vessel that allows blood to bypass the baby's lungs. Generally the ductus close within a few days of birth, and the connections between the two sides of the heart no longer exist. The resistance to blood flow quickly falls with the onset of breathing. In some babies with Down syndrome the ductus fails to close. This causes higher pressure in the left side of the heart and increases the amount of blood flowing into the lungs. If the ductus has partially closed and only a narrow connection remains, the baby won’t show symptoms. If the connection is larger, the baby may be breathless and tired and show poor weight gain. If the ductus remains open for more than three months, it is unlikely to close on its own and surgical closure is recommended. Tetralogy of Fallot. small percentage of babies with Down syndrome have this complex heart condition which combines the most common defect associated with Down syndrome, AVSD, with Tetralogy of Fallot. This anomaly includes four different heart problems: a hole between the top chambers and a hole between the bottom chambers combined mitral and tricuspid valves (common atrioventricular valve) narrowed pulmonary artery (from heart to lungs) or the area under or above the valve, or all three thickening of the right bottom chamber (ventricle) The combination of these defects early in life almost seems to balance out such that the child may be rather blue, but not too breathless. There can, of course, be too much blueness or too much breathlessness, depending on the severity of the different conditions. The type of surgery depends on the severity of the AVSD or the Fallots. Usually, the children are quite blue and require a BT shunt to increase the amount of blue going to the lungs. Then another operation is performed later – usually at 1-2 years of age – so that the holes can be closed, the valves repaired, and the way out to the lung artery widened. Other Heart Related Problems in Down syndrome In addition to the heart defects associated with Down syndrome, high blood pressure in the lungs (pulmonary hypertension) is more common in people with Down syndrome. This high blood pressure may be a result of malformation of the lung tissue, but the exact cause is not known. Higher blood pressure may limit the amount of blood flow to the lungs and therefore decrease the likelihood of symptoms of congestive heart failure seen in babies with complete AV canals or large ventricular septal defects. This then causes the problem of delaying a possible needed surgery to close holes in the heart. These babies must be watched carefully in order to determine the best time for surgery. A majority of cardiologists agree that all babies diagnosed with Down syndrome should have a cardiology evaluation. This is because of the high incidence of associated congenital heart defects. A good history and physical examination should be performed by an experienced cardiologist to rule out any obvious heart defect. Some of the tests that should be addressed when developing a program of study for Downs Syndrome students are:
An electrocardiogram should be performed. This can be very helpful in making the diagnosis of AV canal, even when physical symptoms are absent.
Some doctors also choose to perform at least one echocardiogram to rule out other subtle heart problems.
If the diagnosis of congenital heart disease is made, the cardiologist normally follows up with the child through routine office visits. Most patients can be watched clinically to determine if the child is having difficulty because of the heart defect.
Occasionally, a repeat electrocardiogram, chest X-ray, or echocardiogram is performed to further evaluate clinical changes. These tests are likely to be repeated before surgical repair is recommended.
Rarely, a cardiac catheterization is required for complete evaluation prior to corrective surgery, especially in children where elevated pressures in the lungs are a concern.
Parents of a child with Down syndrome need to work closely with their child’s doctor(s) to determine what route (surgical or medical) will best serve their child.
The first of the more common heart problems is Persistent Ductus Arteriosus. This heart disease the ductus arteriosus is a channel between the pulmonary artery and the aorta. During fetal life it diverts blood away from the lungs because prenatal blood is already oxygenated from the mother. After birth this channel usually closes on the first day of life. If it does not close, it is termed "persistent" and results in an increased flow of blood into the lungs. The second disease commonly associated with Downs Syndrome is Tetralogy of Fallot. This term given to a heart condition composed of four abnormalities: Ventricular septal defect a narrowing of the passage from the right ventrical to the lungs an over enlarged right ventrical because of the backup of blood an over enlarged aorta, which carries blood from the left ventrical to the body. These two congenital heart defects have a profound effect on the respiratory system, and since martial arts training involve a large amount of cardio vascular training, the instructor needs to be aware that the student has physical limitations that need to be carefully monitored. The lungs of children with Down syndrome do not develop as fully as in the general population. Consequently, the growth of blood vessels throughout the lungs is limited. The narrowed arteries of the lungs hold potential for lasting consequences due to the increased pressure and flow of blood through the lungs. There is good news in dealing with this condition; Heart surgery to correct the defects is recommended and it must be done before age five or six months in order to prevent lung damage. Although the complexity of the defects raises the risk of surgery slightly above that of surgery on children without Down syndrome, successful surgery will allow many children with heart conditions to thrive as well as any child with Down syndrome who is born with a normal heart. There may be residual defects (such as imperfect valves in cases of Atrioventricular Septal Defect), but their effect on health is often minimal. So in the evaluation of the Downs syndrome student, it should be enquired as to whether the student presents with this heart disease and if so, what is the current status of their condition.
As can be seen by a review of the literature, Downs Syndrome students with congenital heart disease present many issues for the instructor to take in consideration. These problems should never preclude the student from study, but for safety and liability issues a complete medical history questionnaire should be prepared in order to develop a program of study that will keep the student safe and the instructor will be more prepared to help the student reach their goals and be a proud member of the martial arts community.
Freeman SB, Taft LF, Dooley KJ, Allran K, Sherman SL, Hassold TJ, Khoury MJ, Saker DM (1998), Population-based study of congenital heart defects in Down syndrome.
Am J Med Genet 1998 Nov 16;80(3):213-7, Department of Genetics, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia, USA. Down Syndrome Abstract of the Month: Dec 1998, viewed on 3 April 2009, http://www.ds-health.com/abst/a9812.htm
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, 2006, Heart-Related Syndromes Down Syndrome (Trisomy 21), viewed on 11 April 2009, http://www.cincinnatichildrens.org/health/heart-encyclopedia/anomalies/pda.htm